Sources: Magazines

General Information 

image credit: Ken Hawkins
Magazines_KenHawkins.jpg

Periodicals aimed at a general or nonprofessional audience. Published frequently (usually weekly or biweekly), they cover everything from news and entertainment (Time, Rolling Stone), to amateur science (Sky & Telescope), to recreation and hobbies (Runner's World). 

Strengths:

  • Source for background on significant events, including names, dates, interviews, photographs.
  • Popular perspectives on the social impacts of research
  • Perspectives of particular groups (e.g. Ms. Magazine on feminism.)
  • Reviews of popular literature, art, and film
  • Easily located at libraries, newsstands, and bookstores

Considerations:

  • May be used for clues even when not cited in final paper
  • Be wary of bias; objectivity is a myth. What do you know about the publisher?
  • Does the publication have an editorial slant? Who is responsible for content?
  • Target audience: General public

 

Sources: Newspapers

General Information

image credit: alamode stuff
files.jpg

 Daily publications containing accounts of the day's events and other features. Most newspapers are typically published for a single city or town (The Daily Herald), while papers from the largest cities (The New York Times) have a more global readership, and others target a specialized audience (Wall Street Journal).

Strengths:

  • Local perspectives on a story
  • Primary source for events
  • Good for local news stories too small to be published elsewhere

Considerations:

  • Large city papers may publish separate city and national editions with different content
  • Articles written with newest developments first and background information later (pyramid style.)
  • Back issues of most papers, when available, are normally only on microfilm or in Web archives
  • Web versions usually differ from print versions
  • Target audience: General public, usually in a specific city or region

 

Sources: Broadcast and Internet News

General Information

image credit: Adam Fagen
files.jpg

Television news is broadcast at regular intervals during the day, usually morning, evening, and night, and whenever important news demands that other programming be interrupted. Internet news sites (like CNN.com) are also becoming an important news resource. They can be accessed at any time; they can provide links to other information sources on the Web; and they allow users to explore on their own.

Strengths:

  • Web links allow exploration of related information
  • Immediate access to breaking stories
  • Stories updated regularly and often
  • Access to first-hand interviews & video footage 

Considerations:

  • Internet sites and broadcast media aren't always archived and preserved; stories can "disappear" overnight
  • Commercialism (ads, banners, editorial choices driven by sponsors) may create bias and sensationalism
  • Can be difficult to access the story you want
  • Target audience: General public
  •  

Sources: Invisible College

General Information

image credit: Tim Morgan
files.jpg

Unfiltered, informal communications produced by communities of people who share an interest in a common subject or discipline. E-mail, personal conversations, conference papers, unpublished diaries, meeting minutes, phone calls, newsletters, memoranda, blogs, tweets, and other sources that may not pass through the usual publishing, broadcasting, and distribution channels.

Strengths:

  • Some historically inaccessible information is now made available on the Internet
  • Often available sooner than conventional literature
  • May allow the reader/user to "listen in" on active debate of current issues

Considerations:

  • Dramatic variation in quality
  • Can be hard to identify, search for, and access
  • May require validation of data, especially with Internet sources
  • Assumes a fairly high level of familiarity with an issue or topic
  • Usually not good for gathering background information, but great for gathering clues and easily-overlooked insights
  • Target audience: generally any group sharing a common interest -- you may need to look up some terms

 

Making Sense of Information

Making Sense of Information

We take in so much information in so many different forms every day, it's hard to make sense of it all. In extreme cases, we may even experience "information overload."
So, it's important to understand that information is produced and distributed according to general patterns, often referred to as "Information Cycles." It's not an exact science; but a skilled researcher who understands these patterns and knows which types of information sources are most appropriate for any given project is likely to achieve consistent success in finding what they need.

Timeline

   A news event makes visible the production of information related to it. But that information is part of a continuum that actually begins before the event takes place, is sometimes visible to the public and sometimes not, and may never end, just slow down over time.

Field Searching

Most search engines and databases search "words anywhere" or "keywords" automatically unless you select another type of search.

Keyword searching finds matches for your terms in any field of a record or any part of a Web page, so you will typically retrieve more information with less precision.

Databases and search engines may allow searching in specific fields such as author, title, url (Web address), or subject (which is the most common field to search) and will sometimes refer to this as "advanced," or "expert" searching. These searches will typically retrieve less information with more precision.

If you are a detective and the only clues you have for a missing persons case are the words "red," "blue," and "green," these people could be a match.
searchlineup.png 
This is keyword searching: RED + BLUE + GREEN
If instead you knew your person had a red tie, blue shirt, and a green beret, you have a better chance of finding the right person.
searchlineupresult.png 
This is field searching: Tie= RED, Shirt= BLUE, Beret= GREEN

When should you use a keyword search?
We recommend keyword searching when you are doing either a large original research project or are looking for a rare or unique term (e.g. Eminem). This strategy allows you to find anything remotely related to a topic. Doctoral students and professional researchers typically perform these searches early in their research in order to identify everything already published about their focus area. Keyword searching can also be an effective strategy for identifying subject terms from a few relevant records to prepare for a subject field search later.

When should you use a field search?
We recommend field searching when you need to find a relatively small number of sources on a specific topic. This type of searching is most useful for smaller projects like course term papers, problem-solving activities, and making consumer choices.
 

Records

Records 
Records are the building blocks of databases-- they describe information sources.
Examples:

• Your driver's license is a record describing certain characteristics of the you.
• An entry for Moby Dick in the Library's catalog is a record describing certain characteristics of the book.

 It is unrealistic, at this time, to expect all information sources to come directly to a computer screen on demand. The reasons for this will be clearer to you as you become more experienced finding and using information. Copy of recordsfields.png

In the meantime, having a record describing a source that you can then find using your own abilities and knowledge is an excellent starting point. The description in a record uses elements called metadata [information about information]. In many cases, the text itself will have to be located using other finding tools. Some libraries provide links to the text of articles, when available, at their own expense. 
Fields 
Fields are the building blocks of records-- they are the sections of a record where information is stored.
Examples:

• Your driver's license has fields for information like Name, Eye Color, Height, Address, etc.
• The entry for Moby Dick has fields for Author, Title, Subject, Publisher, and Publication Date.

Database Coverage

Every database contains only certain types and amounts of information, a characteristic called coverage. This information can typically be found in the database itself under links such as "About [name of database]," "Database information," "Title list," or "Sources," etc. Web-based databases are typically accessed from a link that is annotated with some information about coverage. Databases published in paper form normally locate this information in the front of each volume or in an introduction. 

 
Consider the following elements of database coverage: 

What kinds of documents? Databases can include a journals, magazines, books, book chapters, dissertations, audio files, statistical tables, images, Web pages, software applications
What disciplines? General databases may cover many disciplines; subject databases may be more limited in their scope
What time periods? Some databases may cover hundreds of years while others may limit coverage to more recent documents
What languages? Many databases will include documents in a range of languages or provide translation services
Which publication types? Scholarly databases will provide access to academic research sources; general databases may include popular, trade and scholarly works
What is included in the record? Databases subscribe to a large number of publications but may index even more-- while some articles may be available for you to read immediately (full-text), others may only provide an abstract or simply a citation.

Databases

data·base: noun 1. A collection of data arranged for ease and speed of search and retrieval.

 --The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language: Fourth Edition. 2000.

This quality of being " ... arranged for ease and speed of search and retrieval" is what distinguishes a database from a computer network like the Internet, which has no standardized organization principle.

Databases may sometimes be accessed through the Internet, but their contents are not retrieved by search engine services like Google or Yahoo! Most are available through separate Web sites that charge a fee for use, normally paid by libraries on behalf of their users.

Evaluating Websites

How do you evaluate information found on the Web?

One way is to ask questions about who, what, when, where and why the resource was created.

evaluating a webpage

The CRAP Test (Currency, Reliability, Authority, Purpose) is an acronym that represents criteria that can be used in evaluating websites. Web domain names can also provide additional clues to the credibility of sources.

Remember, these questions are guidelines for determining if a resource is credible. Not all websites will meet all the criteria for a credible website. Even if a site doesn't meet all criteria, it may still be credible and useful. For example, information on a website might still be credible even if the site hasn't been updated for many months or even years.

Currency

How recently was the information published? Is the information current enough for your topic?

Having the most up-to-date information is particularly important if your topic is, for example, Health or Science-related. However, date of publication is not as critical for many topics, such as History or Fine Arts. Ultimately, you must make this decision based upon your research needs.

When was the website last updated?

Website update information can often be found at the bottom of the web page.
Depending on the topic, some websites don't need to be updated as frequently as other sites that are more dependent on current information, such as Health or Science-related websites.

Reliability

Does the information creator provide references or sources for data or quotations?

The credibility of a resource is greatly enhanced if the author provides evidence of where they're getting their source information. This evidence can be cited as a footnote, or listed in a bibliography or list of resources, which is typically found at the bottom of an article or webpage.

Is the information accurate? Can you independently verify the accuracy of the information from another source?

To determine if the information is accurate, do an online search or consult a reference resource such as an encyclopedia to verify the accuracy of the information. Encyclopedias and other reference works are available through the Library's databases and print collection. Note: Multiple websites might post the same information using your original website as the source. Try to locate an independent, third-party website, database or print resource that corroborates the information listed in the article or website that you're citing.

Authority

Who is the author or creator?

The name of the author or party responsible for the information is usually located near the title of the article (byline) or near the bottom of the webpage. Occasionally the article or website will not list the name of the author, but rather the organization responsible for producing the information.

What are the author’s credentials? Are they an expert in the field, or, a journalist from a reputable publication?

The author's credentials indicate if the person has had the necessary training to offer an expert opinion on the topic. For example, research conducted by professors, teachers, those who hold advanced degrees and other professionals who work in the field of study are generally considered to be credible. Although not necessarily experts in a particular field, journalists who work for major news outlets may also be considered credible.

To learn more about an author or organization, do an online search of the name in quotation marks. For example, in doing a search for "Jill Lepore" you will find that she is a Professor of American History at Harvard University. This is the first result from the search. Since the website's domain name (the ".edu" part) is from an educational organization, the odds that the website is legitimate are very high. For more information on Domain Names, see below.

Who is the publisher or sponsor of the publication / website? Are they reputable?

Do an online search for the name of the publisher or sponsor of the publication using quotations. For example, doing a search for the "Plastics Industry Trade Association" will take you to the Society of the Plastics Industry: SPI, whose purpose is to promote growth in the U.S. plastics industry. While this is a reputable organization, it does have a vested interest in promoting specific commercial activities. Be alert for motives and biases, particularly for information coming from .COM, .NET and .ORG websites. For more information on Domain Names, click here

Purpose/Point of View

Is the resource based on facts or opinions?

Resources that use facts that are supported by evidence cited in the work are generally considered to be more credible than opinion-based resources. However, depending on your project, opinion pieces can be useful.

If the resource is opinion-based, is it balanced? Are multiple perspectives presented?

As the old saying goes, there are two sides to every story. A well-balanced resource will include multiple perspectives, offering arguments and counter-arguments.

Is the resource biased? Is the author trying to sway your opinion?

Most resources will have a bias. Biases can be "direct", meaning that the bias is clearly stated as a way to persuade the reader to agree with their position. Biases can also be "indirect," by including information that supports their position, and excluding information that does not support the position. It is important to try to identify the author's position so you can use this information in an informed manner.

Is the creator/author trying to sell you something?

There is no shortage of commercial interests trying to sell their wares on the Internet. Sometimes marketeers will cloak sales pitches in the form of a story, essay or news article.


Website Domain Names


Website domain names are the end part of the URL that falls after the "." in a web address. For example, the ".COM" in CNN.COM.

Below are the five common top-level domain names and their general purpose:

  • .COM – Commercial
  • .EDU – Educational institutions
  • .GOV – Government agencies
  • .NET – General purpose
  • .ORG - Organizations

The website domain name can provide insights to why the information is being made available. For example, someone posting information on a “.COM” website might, but not necessarily, be trying to sell you something. Use the CRAP Test and your critical thinking skills to decide if the information you’re assessing is credible and appropriate for your research needs.

Tags: 

Pages

Subscribe to College of DuPage Library RSS